Fiki Coming soon

Fiki · one sentence

In 1835 a New York newspaper put winged people on the Moon.

Everything has a backstory. This one takes about a minute, and every step shows its receipts.

The whole story is below, in order.

New York, the week of 25 August 1835

The Sun said an astronomer had found life on the Moon.

A forest. Miniature bison. A unicorn-like creature. Beavers that stood on two legs. Each day the paper printed more.

Show the receipts (3)
  • The series ran in The New York Sun during the week of 25 August 1835.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • It described a forest with plants, birds and mammals including “a unicorn-like creature”, and “miniature bison and beavers that stood on two legs.”

    What the paper claimedS. Hall

  • The page you inspect here is our drawing, not the original newspaper.

    Our illustrationB. H. Day

The alibi

The astronomer was real. He was in South Africa and could not answer.

The paper credited Sir John Herschel and cited the Edinburgh Journal of Science, through a companion called Andrew Grant. Grant did not exist.

Show the receipts (3)
  • The articles claimed to report discoveries by Sir John Herschel, who was in South Africa, and cited the Edinburgh Journal of Science as their source.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • The story was told through “the fictitious Andrew Grant”, said to have accompanied Herschel.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • Herschel “was not able to respond quickly to deny the claims.”

    On the recordS. Hall

28 August 1835

Then the paper gave the Moon winged people, and many readers stopped believing.

Whatever readers made of the bison and the beavers, the fourth instalment tipped the scales. The next day other newspapers cried hoax.

Show the receipts (3)
  • The 28 August instalment describing winged people “did tip the scales”, and many stopped believing.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • On 29 August several papers “cried hoax”, including The New York Evening Post and The Gloucester Telegraph.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • How many readers believed the earlier instalments, and for how long, is not something our source measures.

    InterpretationS. Hall

The denial

The man many blamed wrote: “I did not make those discoveries.”

Many believed the author was Richard Adams Locke, a British-born journalist. The Sun never retracted the story and never named who wrote it.

Show the receipts (3)
  • Many believed the author was the British-born journalist Richard Adams Locke, and he was accused in the press.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • In a letter to The New York Evening Post dated 31 August, Locke wrote: “I did not make those discoveries.”

    On the recordS. Hall

  • The Sun did not retract the story or name its author, and that drew objections.

    On the recordS. Hall

Edgar Allan Poe

Poe thought the hoax stole his idea. Later, Locke published one of Poe's.

Poe had printed a Moon voyage story two months earlier, which many readers took as fiction. He went on to write “The Great Balloon Hoax”. That one did fool some readers.

Show the receipts (3)
  • Poe published “Hans Phaall, a Tale” in June 1835. Many readers recognised it as fiction.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • Poe suspected the Moon hoax was based on his idea and believed Locke was responsible.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • Poe later wrote “The Great Balloon Hoax”, which was “more successful at fooling some of his readers”, and it was published by Locke.

    On the recordS. Hall

Afterwards

Being exposed made it more famous. It was reprinted at home and abroad.

Some papers ran it with disclaimers. Part of the reason it travelled is that it had become known as a hoax. The correction carried the story further than it had gone alone.

Show the receipts (3)
  • Some papers reprinted the story with disclaimers. It was reprinted at home and abroad, partly because it had become famous as a hoax.

    On the recordS. Hall

  • The hoax's popularity was fuelled by conflicting claims of truth and hoax, and stories about astronomy “could sell newspapers.”

    On the recordS. Hall

  • That a debunked story can spread because it was debunked is a pattern people now describe online. Our source is about 1835 and draws no such comparison. We do, and it is only a comparison.

    InterpretationS. Hall

The receipts

What this step rests on, and how sure anyone can be.

Sources for this story

The newspaper page is our own drawing, set in modern type. It is not a facsimile of The Sun.

Be here when the door opens

This story is a first look. Fiki, the playground for the endlessly curious, is still being built.

Email us for an invitation

The sign-up list is not open yet, and this page collects nothing. The button opens your own email app with a message to hello@fiki.life. Nothing is sent unless you send it, and you are not added to any automatic list.

More from Fiki